May 2, 1996
". . . I find your and your group's page informative and very thorough. I am part German and Hungarian where I received part of my real education. I will be going to Germany this summer.
Being an Engineering graduate, I believe that math never lies, but you don't have to be to understand the following logic (if you consider) that one, roughly needs the heat energy of 300 Kg of coal to combust one person. Multiply this by 6 Million (the persons in question) and you get 1.8 Million Tons of coal-which is way above the capacities of Germany during the war.
So if bodies were not burned, where are they ?
The question of time. One needs 2 hr. today with modern ovens to burn one person and need to produce thousands of BTU 's of energy. Take that 2 hr. and divide it by a day. This works out to 12 bodies without time in between, even with 100 crematories (this is more than existing sites today)
One cannot burn the missing numbers!
Keep in mind the time span from 1943 May to 1945 March which is 660 days. This will only produce 792, 000 bodies max-not even close to a seven digit figure! (6 Mill)
The question of energy, the law of conservation of mass is true! Nothing is lost or gained; it's transformed!
Where would all that energy (have) come from to fuel these so-called ovens? And nobody could miss the combustion products, the gases and smell. I don't think the Germans would waste the coal, gas or fuel to dispose of the Jews when they hardly had enough fuel to run the tanks!
It does not make sense! Thank you!"
Thank YOU! A little common sense and grammar school arithmetic will
go a long, long way!
However, there might be another explanation. I found the following some
time ago and had it recently translated:
The Natural Sciences and Technology under National Socialism:
A Dry Analysis of Special Interest to Engineers
Over a period of almost 5 decades the act of "Coming to Terms with the Past" has illuminated every nook and cranny of National-Socialist activity in war and peace.
There is however one phenomenon which, until today, has not been described nor explored, and this is that this cynical ("Nazi") system managed to impose its own laws even on nature itself.
We present the following arguments in support of this claim.
1. The fourth law of thermodynamics, the so-called National-Socialist one, asserts that under certain political conditions, the effects of the other three laws may be limited.
Proof: Corpses burn like dry wood in the force-field of National Socialism . The burning can be enhanced with the addition of water, as the following practical cases demonstrate.
At the Jerusalem Trial of J. Demnjaniuk, eyewitness Elyiahu Rosenberg stated that "after the Germans discovered that women and children burn better than adult males, we had to throw the corpses of men into the fire only at the end." (Münchener Abendzeitung, 27.2.87)
Remark: A person consists of between 60 and 70 % of water. The higher percentage holds for the bodies children, which, according to eye-witness testimony, burnt best of all.
The witness Szyia Warszawsky stated that "when the corpses caught fire, they burnt on their own." (Main record of The Investigation of Nazi Crimes in Poland).
A statement by French-Jewish doctor C.S. Bendel, sworn on 2.3.46 before an Allied military tribunal in Hamburg, stated that "it is an actual fact that 1000 bodies thrown into such a ditch disappeared within an hour, they turned into ashes". (Document reprinted in U. Walendy, "Auschwitz in IG Farben Prozess", Vlotho 1981, p.58)2. The National-Socialist law of compact packing or the compression of matter without pressure.
This was applied in order to pack the optimum number of victims into a gas chamber. According to eyewitness Dr. Bendel (ibid, p.55), "One thousand people were brought into a room with dimensions 10 by 4 by 1,6 meters (64 cubic meters) [...] This could only be achieved by the German method."
Explanation: The body of an adult fits into a National-Socialist cube of side 40 centimetres.3. The law of specific National-Socialist gas circulation. (Spontaneous homogeneous diffusion in a strongly inhomogeneous cavity-system).
This was confirmed by Judge Melder who tried Ernst Zündel in November 1991 at Munich:
In a gas chamber packed full with people the slowly liberated poison-gas spreads itself evenly throughout the gas chamber without any fall in concentration.4. The law of total annihilation of matter.
Proof: At least at Treblinka around 800 000 murdered people disappeared without leaving a trace.
5. The National-Socialist principle of oxidation. (Burning with a throttled supply of oxygen or without oxygen altogether).
Applied for the disposal of traces during and after mass-murder of Jews in Poland.
According to perpetrator Rudolf Hoess, "[...] for the most part, those gassed were burnt behind Crematorium IV [...] The bodies were at first burnt with oil residue, later by pouring on methanol. In the ditches corpses were burnt continuously, that is day and night." (Martin Broszat (Ed.) "Commandant in Auschwitz", Munich 1981, p.165 and p.161 respectively).
Witness Szlama Dragon on the burning of corpses at Auschwitz (statement made on 11.5.45): "[...] there were two 30m long 7m wide and 3m deep ditches at Auschwitz. The edges of the pits were blackened by smoke". (Kogon, Langbein & Rückerl: "Nationalsozialistische Massentötung durch Giftgas" ("National-Socialist Mass-Murder with Poison-Gas"), Frankfurt/M 1983, p.211).
Explanation: In a hole in the ground fire has normally an insufficient supply of oxygen. Without National-Socialist technology it is impossible even today to burn wood and paper piles in a 3-metre deep ditch, let alone heaps of bodies.
Remark: Application of the National-Socialist oxidation principle found its perfect fulfilment at Auschwitz, namely under water. For, in the vicinity of the camp the water table reaches a level just beneath the surface of the ground. (Compare the photograph in the Magazine of the paper S=FCdeutschen Zeitung of 6.12.91, where one can observe a pool of water next to Crematorium IV). The burning-ditches were thus full of water.6. The law of racially determined sensitivity to hydrocyanic acid. (The selective effect of HCN on homo sapiens Hebraeicus).
Proof: The gas chambers at Auschwitz were in the immediate vicinity of other camp facilities, for instance the SS field hospital. Continuous ventilation of the gas chambers would certainly not have affected the guard detail - clearly a genetically determined phenomenon. Also, following a still to be unravelled National-Socialist method, the Jewish work details would have been immune to poison, since they hauled the corpses out of the gas chambers without any protective clothing, gloves or gas-masks. (M. Broszat, op. cit. p.130).
7. The gas chamber effect.
In the force-field of a National-Socialist gas chamber there occurs a wave alteration effect, so that the invisible becomes visible.
Eyewitness Boeck, a member of the guard detail, announced during the 1964-1965 Frankfurt Auschwitz trial that he saw disposal squads working in the blue haze of Hydrogen cyanide gas.
Hint: Hydrogen Cyanide is normally colourless; ie. invisible. (Note 1)8. The National Socialist principle for generating carbon monoxide with the help of a Diesel engine.
Proof in the case of Treblinka: "There was a Diesel motor in an annex which generated poison gas." (Kogon, Langbein, Rückerl, op.cit., p.163).
Proof in the case of Belzec: "The engine itself stood there [...], it was Diesel-driven". (K. Gerstein, quoted in Kogon, Langbein & Rückerl, op.cit. p.173).
Hint: At that time, to all practical purposes the ideal poison-gas generator would have been readily available in the form of one for generating producer-gas from wood. With 32% of its volume consisting of carbon monoxide, the propellant gas formed contained a high proportion of this highly toxic gas. (Meyer's Encyclopedia/Lexicon, 1974, vol. 12, p.207).
It is clear that special wartime circumstances determined that producer-gas generators should have been retained for the maintenance of truck transport on the home front. Thus the extermination camps in the East had to make do with Diesel engines, which even under present political conditions can only emit non-dangerous concentrations of about 0.5% carbon monoxide. (Meyer's Encyclopedia/Lexicon, 1971, vol.1, p.88). Nevertheless, the circumstances prevailing during the National Socialist reign made it clearly possible to gain substantially greater emissions of carbon monoxide from a diesel engine, contrary to the design of its inventor. In any case one had to sacrifice extremely scarce Diesel fuel for this purpose; the producer-gas carburator would have had to make do with wood shavings.
The disclosure by natural scientists and technologists of these examples of the fearful capabilities of the terror regime (to name only a few) has been long overdue. For, only the knowledge of these things can neatly round off our picture of National Socialism.
It is amazing that the world has not yet been informed of this, even though the victors carried off thousands of scientists as well as all patents and research results as booty from a vanquished Germany._____
(Note 1) Remark of the translator. The German word for hydrocyanic acid (HCN), Blausäure, named after the blue in Prussian Blue, itself a cyanide compound, iron, might suggest to the ignorant that HCN should have a blue coloration. In order to sound more authentic perhaps Boeck thought this would be a realistic detail...
Ingrid
Thought for the Day:
"In larger things we are convivial; What causes trouble is the trivial."
(Richard Armour)